Kalvin Phillips, the beloved defensive midfielder, was mobbed by fans on Olympic Way after Leeds United’s play-off final defeat to Southampton at Wembley Stadium. Despite leaving Elland Road two summers ago for a £42 million transfer to Manchester City, Phillips has struggled to find playing time under Pep Guardiola and a loan spell at West Ham United failed to revive his England career.
As Manchester City celebrated their Premier League victory, Phillips was surrounded by adoring fans at Wembley, his characteristic grin a testament to the unconditional support he receives from the Leeds faithful. The scenes resembled a populist leader being mobbed after an election victory, rather than a former player visiting his old club.
A return to Elland Road this summer would make sense, given Phillips’ history with the club and his desire to revive his career. However, Premier League sides may be hesitant to gamble on the 28-year-old, whose City contract and sporadic playing time make him a risky investment. Even a loan or permanent move to a bottom-half Premier League team might not be deemed value-for-money.
Had Leeds won promotion to the Premier League, a homecoming for Phillips would have been a strong possibility. He might have accepted a reduced wage to return to his beloved club and revive his career. However, with Leeds remaining in the Championship, the likelihood of Phillips’ return has diminished.
Leeds would need to commit significant resources to secure Phillips’ services, which might not be justified given his recent performances. Meanwhile, Phillips’ current deal with City has four years left to run, and top-flight clubs abroad may offer more attractive alternatives.
While Daniel Farke has highlighted the need for a “deep six” option like Phillips, the financial realities and Phillips’ desire to play at the top level make a return to Leeds unlikely. The coming weeks and months will be instructive for both Phillips’ future and that of Leeds United.